Skip to content
Please be aware the content below has been generated by an AI model from a source PDF.

Capercaillie Emergency Plan scientific advisory group meeting notes - October 2026

Sci­entif­ic Advis­ory Group — Caper­cail­lie Emer­gency Plan Meet­ing note Thursday 29 Octo­ber, 1pm — 3pm | Park Author­ity Office, Grant­own-on-Spey and Teams

Attendees

  • Alice Broome: Seni­or Sci­ent­ist — Pri­or­ity spe­cies / hab­it­ats, Forest Research
  • Car­o­lyn Robertson: Cairngorms Nature Man­ager, Park Authority
  • Chris Suth­er­land: Read­er of Stat­ist­ics, Uni­ver­sity of St Andrews
  • Dave Par­ish: Ter­restri­al Orni­tho­lo­gist, NatureScot
  • Helen Senn: Head of Con­ser­va­tion and Sci­ence Pro­grammes, RZSS
  • Holly Niven: Research Assist­ant, Uni­ver­sity of Glasgow
  • Jason Mat­thi­opoulos: Head of Eco­logy and Envir­on­ment­al Change, Uni­ver­sity of Glasgow
  • Kath Leys: Head of Biod­iversity and Geo­di­versity, NatureScot (Chair)
  • Kathy Fletch­er: Seni­or Sci­ent­ist Scot­tish Upland Research, GWCT
  • Steven Ewing: Seni­or Con­ser­va­tion Sci­ent­ist, RSPB

Apo­lo­gies

  • Xavi­er Lambin: Pro­fess­or of Eco­logy, Uni­ver­sity of Aberdeen

1. Caper­cail­lie Integ­rated Pop­u­la­tion Mod­el development

Holly provided an update on the latest devel­op­ment of the Caper­cail­lie Integ­rated Pop­u­la­tion Mod­el (CIPM) and feed­back from a sur­vey com­pleted by group mem­bers to help pri­or­it­ise devel­op­ments. The group dis­cussed the value of involving more stake­hold­ers in the model’s devel­op­ment, while man­aging expect­a­tions about what can be real­ist­ic­ally delivered. A pro­posed stake­hold­er day in February/​March 2027 could provide an oppor­tun­ity for this.

Increas­ing oppor­tun­it­ies to link the CIPM with CaperMap to present mod­el out­puts spa­tially were dis­cussed. Mem­bers of the group also expressed interest in explor­ing fur­ther how extreme events and the risk of pop­u­la­tion extinc­tion are rep­res­en­ted with­in the mod­el and agreed that a fol­low-up dis­cus­sion would be valuable.

Holly presen­ted example graphs with lek-spe­cif­ic pop­u­la­tion tra­ject­or­ies. These mod­el out­puts could help track how pop­u­la­tions respond to man­age­ment inter­ven­tions in dif­fer­ent areas and identi­fy where future man­age­ment efforts should be focused.

Fol­low­ing dis­cus­sion at the pre­vi­ous meet­ing about the tim­ing of the next Nation­al Sur­vey, mod­el­ling res­ults were shared indic­at­ing that under­tak­ing the sur­vey in 2029⁄30, rather than earli­er would res­ult in the low­est level of uncer­tainty by allow­ing for a longer peri­od of data collection.

Pro­ductiv­ity data are included in the mod­el, and the group dis­cussed the trans­ition in pro­ductiv­ity mon­it­or­ing meth­ods from point­er dog counts to cam­era traps. It was noted that an ongo­ing study by GWCT, con­duc­ted as part of the Emer­gency Plan, shows the two approaches are pro­du­cing broadly com­par­able res­ults. The cur­rent two-year peri­od of over­lap will allow for cross-cal­ib­ra­tion between meth­ods and help main­tain con­tinu­ity in the data. This has been demon­strated by sim­il­ar changes in mon­it­or­ing meth­ods for oth­er species.

2. Review the draft Research and Mon­it­or­ing Plan

The group provided feed­back on the latest draft of the Research and Mon­it­or­ing Plan, which had been updated fol­low­ing dis­cus­sions at the pre­vi­ous meet­ing and com­ments received since. The revised draft also included inform­a­tion from the Cairngorms Nature Index (CNI).

The group raised the fol­low­ing points:

  • Know­ledge gaps: Gaps in under­stand­ing of inver­teb­rates as a prey base for caper­cail­lie, and the poten­tial impacts of dis­ease, should be reflec­ted in the rel­ev­ant table in the plan.
  • Cairngorms Nature Index: The plan should align with the Cairngorms Nature Index. A dis­cus­sion was had about the CNI ref­er­ence con­di­tion for caper­cail­lie, includ­ing the suit­ab­il­ity of using Fin­land as a com­par­is­on giv­en poten­tial dif­fer­ence in future cli­mate pro­jec­tions. There was interest in explor­ing how the CIPM could help inform a more dynam­ic ref­er­ence con­di­tion that accounts for envir­on­ment­al change. The group dis­cussed the import­ance of recog­nising dif­fer­ent stages of pop­u­la­tion recov­ery, from achiev­ing a min­im­um viable pop­u­la­tion, through sta­bil­ity, towards a more nat­ur­al pop­u­la­tion level con­sist­ent with good eco­lo­gic­al con­di­tion. It was also sug­ges­ted that his­tor­ic­al data used to estab­lish the CNI ref­er­ence con­di­tion could help improve the model’s abil­ity to estim­ate past pop­u­la­tion trends and reduce uncertainty.
  • Fund­ing: High-level fig­ures in the fund­ing table could be broken down to sup­port oper­a­tion­al budget plan­ning and provide great­er clar­ity about how fund­ing would be used.
  • Com­mu­nic­a­tions and engage­ment: The pro­posed stake­hold­er event in February/​March 2027 was iden­ti­fied as a poten­tial oppor­tun­ity to launch the plan, explain its pur­pose and bring its con­tent to life, help­ing to build under­stand­ing and avoid mis­in­ter­pret­a­tion. A com­mu­nic­a­tions plan is also being developed to sup­port pub­lic­a­tion. It was noted that the inclu­sion of a gloss­ary in the plan would help to make it more access­ible and avoid misunderstandings.

3. Roundtable updates

Updates were shared on deliv­ery of the Emer­gency Plan. Pro­gress high­lighted included:

  • Wood­land graz­ing: Approx­im­ately 270 cattle are now graz­ing across 11 sites, influ­en­cing over 6,000 hec­tares of caper­cail­lie hab­it­at. Baseline sur­veys using the Wood­land Herb­i­vore Impact Assess­ment meth­od­o­logy have been under­taken at sev­er­al sites.
  • Rob­ocut­ting: Hun­dreds of hec­tares of dense heath­er have been rob­ocut across mul­tiple land­hold­ings, with fur­ther work under­way. Baseline veget­a­tion sur­veys have been under­taken at sev­er­al sites.
  • Forest bog res­tor­a­tion: Work is planned for the spring to identi­fy pri­or­ity sites to restore dur­ing 2027⁄28, com­ple­ment­ing Peat­land ACTION funding.
  • Diver­sion­ary feed­ing: Delivered across 19 sites in 2026, with pro­ductiv­ity res­ults avail­able in Janu­ary 2027 to inform the next breed­ing season.
  • Deer fence remov­al: Over 12km removed with­in 5km of act­ive leks in the last six months, with a fur­ther 5km iden­ti­fied for remov­al before the next breed­ing sea­son. Approx­im­ately 120km remains. Accel­er­ated remov­al is a pri­or­ity, with pro­gress tracked through the fence inventory.
  • Vole sur­veys: Vole Sign Index and live trap­ping sur­veys are com­plete for 2026, with a ​‘vole day’ planned for Janu­ary 2027 to share find­ings, bring togeth­er land man­agers with a grow­ing interest in vole mon­it­or­ing and explore oppor­tun­it­ies to coordin­ate efforts and expand sur­vey coverage.
  • Stake­hold­er engage­ment: A caper­cail­lie stake­hold­er day is pro­posed for February/​March 2027 to share pro­gress and pro­ductiv­ity res­ults and devel­op good prac­tice guid­ance for hab­it­at inter­ven­tions, includ­ing rob­ocut­ting and wood­land grazing.
  • CaperMap: Work con­tin­ues to secure remain­ing data­sets. Early access for Holly and RSPB staff would sup­port CIPM devel­op­ment and hab­it­at suit­ab­il­ity modelling.
  • Inver­teb­rate data: Macro-moth records and inver­teb­rate trap­ping data from Ron Sum­mers’ caper­cail­lie study have been iden­ti­fied, poten­tially inform­ing under­stand­ing of inver­teb­rate bio­mass and future monitoring.
  • Pred­at­or research: A study on caper­cail­lie responses to pred­at­ors (and recre­ation) is near­ing com­ple­tion. NatureScot’s pine marten sur­vey has been pub­lished, with repeat sur­veys sub­ject to fund­ing. Exist­ing Pred­at­or Pro­ject data may also be useful.
  • Hab­it­at suit­ab­il­ity mod­el­ling: Ini­tial work by the RSPB is pro­gress­ing, with oppor­tun­it­ies to align it with the CIPM.
  • Mon­it­or­ing hab­it­at inter­ven­tions: The final report from the large-scale field-lay­er dis­turb­ance tri­al in RSPB Aber­nethy is expec­ted in 2027. It was sug­ges­ted that the group could con­trib­ute to the devel­op­ment of sur­vey meth­od­o­lo­gies for graz­ing and rob­ocut­ting, identi­fy­ing oppor­tun­it­ies to strengthen mon­it­or­ing and sup­port deliv­ery, includ­ing through stu­dent involvement.

4. Caper­cail­lie pop­u­la­tion rein­force­ment feasibility

Ahead of a joint meet­ing with the Pro­gramme Board to dis­cuss the find­ings and recom­mend­a­tions of the Caper­cail­lie Rein­force­ment Feas­ib­il­ity Study, the group con­sidered the study. Both phases have now been pub­lished and cir­cu­lated to stake­hold­ers. It was noted that some stake­hold­ers have expressed an interest in pur­su­ing rein­force­ment. Sub­ject to fur­ther dis­cus­sion with the Pro­gramme Board, the group con­sidered how best to respond to this interest, includ­ing the import­ance of under­stand­ing and man­aging poten­tial risks, par­tic­u­larly around dis­ease, and identi­fy­ing oppor­tun­it­ies for mon­it­or­ing and learn­ing should pro­pos­als progress.

Actions

  1. Car­o­lyn to arrange a fol­low-up dis­cus­sion to explore how the CIPM mod­els dis­aster scenarios.
  2. Car­o­lyn to update the draft Research and Mon­it­or­ing Plan in response to the feed­back shared.
  3. Car­o­lyn to share a draft com­mu­nic­a­tions plan for the Research and Mon­it­or­ing Plan.
  4. Car­o­lyn to invite Adam, the Park Authority’s Cairngorms Nature Index lead, to present the wood­land eco­sys­tem com­pon­ent of the Nature Index at the group’s next meeting.
  5. Car­o­lyn to include a review of mon­it­or­ing meth­od­o­lo­gies for wood­land graz­ing and rob­ocut­ting at the group’s next meeting.